%20me.png)
When One Partner Isn’t Sure: Finding Your Way Through Relationship Ambivalence
- Jessicah Walker Herche, PhD, HSPP
- Jan 20
- 4 min read
Few moments cut as deep as the one where you realize you and your partner are in different places about the relationship.
One of you still believes in what could be rebuilt. The other isn’t sure if it can be rebuilt at all.
It’s the kind of realization that takes your breath away—not because love is gone, but because it’s still there. You can feel it, even as you’re standing on opposite sides of a widening gap.
The Threshold of Uncertainty
When one partner is “all in” and the other is a “question mark,” the relationship enters a kind of liminal space—a threshold between what was and what might be.
For the partner who’s all in, the uncertainty can feel unbearable: If we love each other, shouldn’t that be enough to keep going?
For the partner who’s unsure, the pressure to decide can feel equally overwhelming: I don’t want to hurt you, but I don’t know what’s true for me anymore.
These moments aren’t a sign of failure; they’re often a sign that the first version of your relationship has reached its limit. The old way of doing things—how you communicate, handle conflict, or seek comfort—has stopped working.
The ambivalence is rarely about love versus indifference. It’s usually about hope versus self-protection.
“I love you, but I don’t know if we can keep doing this,” isn’t a contradiction—it’s the nervous system saying, I want to believe, but I don’t feel safe yet.
When the Field Between You Polarizes
Emotionally, this is where couples get caught in a painful dance.
One partner leans in—talking, reaching, fighting for connection.
The other steps back—quieting, avoiding, seeking calm.
Both are trying to find safety, just in opposite ways.
To the “all in” partner, the other’s withdrawal can feel like rejection.
To the uncertain partner, the other’s pursuit can feel like pressure.
And suddenly, what began as dissonance becomes polarization: one speeding up to save the relationship, the other slowing down to survive it.
Naming this dynamic matters. It helps both partners understand that the tension between them isn’t a lack of love—it’s the relationship’s nervous system trying to stabilize.
When partners move in opposite directions—one pursuing, one withdrawing—the work often begins with re-establishing emotional safety. This process, called co-regulation, helps both nervous systems settle enough to connect again.
What You Need to Know
This is common.
Many long-term, loving relationships pass through this kind of crisis. It doesn’t mean your story is over—it means the current chapter can’t continue as it is.
You don’t need to have the answers yet.
The first task isn’t deciding whether to stay or go. It’s creating enough calm and safety that each of you can actually see what’s true.
Pressure doesn’t create clarity.
The partner who’s unsure isn’t broken or resistant—they’re often flooded, overwhelmed, or scared. And the partner who’s all in isn’t needy—they’re fighting for connection. Both are doing what they’ve learned to do when love feels uncertain.
This isn’t the end—it’s a turning point.
Whether you ultimately stay together or separate, this phase can become one of the most honest and growth-filled seasons of your life.
If You Decide to Stay
If you both choose to stay and make it work, it’s important to know that you aren’t returning to the old marriage or partnership—you’re creating a new one.
You’re divorcing from the first version of the relationship and beginning anew. That means grieving what didn’t work, making new agreements, and slowly rebuilding trust through experience, not promises.
You’re no longer trying to fix the past—you’re learning how to build something sturdier from what you’ve learned.
This process is tender, imperfect, and deeply brave.
Rebuilding a new version of your relationship often means learning to understand each other’s emotional needs in a new way. Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) helps couples do exactly that—creating safety, repair, and deeper connection.
If Clarity Means Letting Go
Sometimes, clarity reveals that staying would require one or both of you to keep betraying your own needs or truth. When that happens, letting go isn’t a failure—it’s an act of integrity.
Even endings can be sacred when they’re handled with honesty and care.
Love doesn’t always end when the relationship does. Sometimes it simply changes form.
Moving Through the Uncertainty
So what helps when you’re in this painful in-between?
Slow down. Don’t rush decisions from panic.
Get support. A skilled couples therapist can help you make sense of what’s happening beneath the surface.
Speak truth gently. Share your feelings, not verdicts.
Stay curious. Ask questions like, What makes this feel unsafe for you? or What would help you feel closer right now?
The goal isn’t to convince—it’s to understand.
If You're Here...
If you’re here, it means you’re already doing something brave: facing the truth of where you are instead of pretending everything’s fine.
This space between “stay” and “go” can feel unbearable—but it’s also where truth ripens.
Whether your relationship heals or transforms into something different, this isn’t the end of love. It’s love asking to become something truer.
If you and your partner are in this season of uncertainty, therapy can help you find clarity, compassion, and a way forward—together or apart. Learn more about couples therapy at Cadence Psychology Studio.
Cadence Psychology Studio offers therapy for individuals and couples in Carmel, Fishers, and throughout PSYPACT-participating states via telehealth. Together, we’ll work toward a steadier rhythm of understanding, connection, and growth.
Reach out to schedule your session today.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this blog is for educational purposes only and is not intended to replace professional psychological care, professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
